Sump pumps · pump styles

Pedestal vs submersible sump pumps

A pedestal pump keeps its motor up on a column above the pit. A submersible pump sits sealed at the bottom of the pit, under water. Both can protect a basement. The right choice depends on pit size, how much water comes in, noise tolerance, and how you want to service the pump. A licensed plumber should confirm the fit before you replace or switch styles.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon.

Bottom line Most finished basements with a standard 18″-plus basin use a cast iron submersible. It is quieter, the pit can be sealed, and it handles heavy inflow well. Pedestals make sense for narrow or shallow pits, light inflow, and owners who want the motor out of the water where it is easy to reach. Either way, size the pump to inflow and lift (see choosing a primary sump pump), add a backup, and have a licensed plumber handle discharge and code questions.

How each style works

Side-by-side

PedestalSubmersible
Pit fitWorks in narrow or small basins where a submersible plus float will not fitNeeds room for the pump body and switch travel. Many makers list a minimum basin diameter.
NoiseLouder. The motor runs in open air in the room.Quieter. Water and a sealed lid muffle the motor.
ServiceabilityMotor and switch are easy to see and reachMust be lifted out of the pit for service. Consider a union and shutoff on the discharge.
Motor cooling and lifeOut of the water and away from debrisWater-cooled. Cast iron housings shed heat well under long run times.
CapacityOften aimed at light-to-moderate inflowWide range, including higher-flow models for heavy inflow
Sealed or radon lidHarder. The column passes through the lid.Easier with a gasketed lid. See radon-sealed sump covers.
SafetyExposed motor in the room. Keep kids and pets away.Enclosed in the pit under a lid

Pit depth and diameter

Cast iron vs thermoplastic

Both styles come in cast iron and engineered thermoplastic. Cast iron housings are heavier and shed motor heat well, so they are a common pick for primary pumps in basements that see frequent cycling. Thermoplastic pumps are lighter and cost less, and they suit light inflow or utility duty. Brand, switch quality, and correct sizing matter as much as housing material.

Switching from one style to the other

When to call a pro

Getting help

Start with a licensed plumber to confirm pump style, basin fit, and discharge. R.E. Merrill & Associates has handled industrial and municipal pumps and fluid systems since 1987. Contact R.E. Merrill & Associates with general pump questions.

Related across the site

Sources

More in this section