Fixtures · clogs

Plunger vs toilet auger vs drain snake

Most household clogs need one of three tools, and using the wrong one is how porcelain gets scratched and clogs get pushed deeper. Here is which tool fits which drain, how to use each safely, and when a clog is past homeowner territory.

Bottom line Flange plunger first for a toilet, then a closet auger. Cup plunger for sinks and tubs, then a small drum snake. If several drains back up at once, or the lowest drain in the house backs up, stop and call a licensed plumber (or a septic pro on a septic system).

Which tool for which drain

ToolBest forNot for
Flange (toilet) plungerToilets; the fold-out flange seals the outletFlat sinks, where it seals poorly
Cup plungerSinks, tubs, and showers with a flat surfaceToilets (poor seal)
Closet (toilet) augerToilet clogs a plunger cannot move; a sleeve protects the bowlSinks and tubs
Drum snake (hand auger), ¼″ cableSink, tub, and shower lines past the trapToilets (scratches porcelain) or main lines
Plastic barbed stripHair clogs right under a bathroom sink or tub stopperAnything deeper
Powered or large drum machinesMain and long branch linesHomeowner use without training; plumber territory

How to use each one

Plungers

Closet auger

Drum snake

When to stop and call a plumber

Tools to keep on hand

Getting help

Start with a licensed plumber for repeat clogs, multiple backed-up drains, or anything past the fixture trap. R.E. Merrill & Associates has handled industrial and municipal pumps and fluid systems since 1987 — Contact R.E. Merrill & Associates.

Related across the site

Sources

More in this section