Fixtures · clogs
Plunger vs toilet auger vs drain snake
Most household clogs need one of three tools, and using the wrong one is how porcelain gets scratched and clogs get pushed deeper. Here is which tool fits which drain, how to use each safely, and when a clog is past homeowner territory.
Bottom line
Flange plunger first for a toilet, then a closet auger. Cup plunger for sinks and tubs, then a small drum snake. If several drains back up at once, or the lowest drain in the house backs up, stop and call a licensed plumber (or a septic pro on a septic system).
Which tool for which drain
| Tool | Best for | Not for |
|---|---|---|
| Flange (toilet) plunger | Toilets; the fold-out flange seals the outlet | Flat sinks, where it seals poorly |
| Cup plunger | Sinks, tubs, and showers with a flat surface | Toilets (poor seal) |
| Closet (toilet) auger | Toilet clogs a plunger cannot move; a sleeve protects the bowl | Sinks and tubs |
| Drum snake (hand auger), ¼″ cable | Sink, tub, and shower lines past the trap | Toilets (scratches porcelain) or main lines |
| Plastic barbed strip | Hair clogs right under a bathroom sink or tub stopper | Anything deeper |
| Powered or large drum machines | Main and long branch lines | Homeowner use without training; plumber territory |
How to use each one
Plungers
- Make sure there is water covering the cup; you are pushing water, not air.
- On a double sink, plug the other side. On a tub, cover the overflow with a wet rag.
- Start gently to seat the seal, then use firm in-and-out strokes about 15–20 times.
Closet auger
- Pull the cable back into the tube, set the rubber-sleeved bend in the bowl outlet, and crank while feeding.
- Retract while cranking. Do not force it; toilets have a tight built-in trap.
Drum snake
- Often it is easier to remove the P-trap and feed the cable into the wall pipe.
- Feed until you feel resistance, lock the cable, and turn the drum to bore through or grab the clog.
- Wear gloves and eye protection, and never mix a snake with chemical drain cleaners already in the line.
When to stop and call a plumber
- More than one fixture is backed up, or water comes up a floor drain when you run water elsewhere.
- On a septic system with a whole-house backup — see septic backup: what to do.
- The toilet rocks or leaks at the base after the clog clears — see wax ring and flange.
- You dropped something solid (a toy, a phone) into the toilet. Augering can lodge it deeper; the toilet may need to be pulled.
- Clogs keep returning in the same drain — a camera inspection may be worth it.
Tools to keep on hand
- Flange toilet plungers (Amazon search) — one per bathroom avoids carrying a dirty plunger through the house
- Closet augers (Amazon search, high to low) — look for a rubber or vinyl bowl guard
- 25-ft drum snakes (Amazon search, high to low) — for sink and tub lines past the trap
- Cup plungers (Amazon search) — for sinks, tubs, and showers
Getting help
Start with a licensed plumber for repeat clogs, multiple backed-up drains, or anything past the fixture trap. R.E. Merrill & Associates has handled industrial and municipal pumps and fluid systems since 1987 — Contact R.E. Merrill & Associates.
Related across the site
Sources
- Tool manufacturer instructions for closet augers and drum snakes.
- Local plumbing code and a licensed plumber for the specific home.