Fixtures · toilets

Toilet fill valve and flapper fixes

A toilet that runs, hisses, refills on its own, or fills slowly almost always comes down to two parts in the tank: the fill valve and the flapper. Both are inexpensive and replaceable without special tools — once you know which one is at fault.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon searches.

Bottom line If water is spilling into the overflow tube, the fill valve or water level is the problem. If the tank slowly empties into the bowl, it is the flapper or flush-valve seat. Match the flapper size (2-inch or 3-inch) and type to your toilet, set the water level to the mark, and leave a little slack in the chain.
Before you start Know where the fixture shutoffs and the main house shutoff are, and test that they close fully. Put a towel and a bucket under the work. If a valve will not close or a fitting is corroded, stop and call a licensed plumber before something snaps.

Find the cause first

  1. Take off the tank lid and watch. Is water running into the overflow tube? Then the level is set too high or the fill valve will not shut off.
  2. If not, add a few drops of food coloring or a dye tablet to the tank. Do not flush for 15–20 minutes.
  3. Colored water in the bowl means the flapper or its seat is leaking.
  4. Also check the chain: too short holds the flapper open; too long can tangle under it.

Symptoms and fixes

SymptomLikely partFix
Constant running into the overflow tubeFill valve or float set too highLower the float; replace the fill valve if it will not shut off
Refills on its own every so often (“phantom flush”)Flapper or seat leakingReplace the flapper; clean or repair the seat
Slow fill or hissingWorn or debris-clogged fill valve, or partly closed shutoffOpen the shutoff fully, flush the valve cap, or replace it
Weak flushWater level too low, flapper closing too early, or clogged rim jetsRaise level to the mark, adjust the flapper, clean jets
Handle must be held downChain too long or flapper too heavyShorten the chain slightly or adjust the flapper float
Water on the floorSupply line, tank bolts, or wax ring — not the fill valveSee supply lines; a base leak is often a plumber call

Replacing a flapper

  1. Shut off the toilet’s supply valve and flush to empty the tank.
  2. Note your flush-valve opening: most are 2-inch or 3-inch. Many newer, higher-efficiency toilets use 3-inch flappers; some brands use a canister or tower seal instead of a flapper.
  3. Unhook the chain and slip the old flapper off its ears or ring.
  4. Wipe the seat smooth with a soft pad; mineral buildup or pitting can keep a new flapper from sealing.
  5. Fit the new flapper and set the chain with about a half inch of slack.
  6. Turn the water on, flush several times, and dye-test again.

Toilet maker’s original flappers usually seal best, especially on high-efficiency toilets tuned for a specific flush volume.

Replacing a fill valve

  1. Shut off the water, flush, and sponge out the last water in the tank.
  2. Disconnect the supply line under the tank and unscrew the locknut holding the old valve.
  3. Set the new valve height to match the tank: the critical level mark should sit at least an inch above the overflow tube, per the maker’s instructions.
  4. Hand-tighten the locknut plus a small turn; do not crack the tank.
  5. Clip the refill tube to the overflow tube above the water line — not pushed down inside it, which can siphon water.
  6. Reconnect the supply line, turn on the water, and set the float so the level matches the line in the tank or sits about an inch below the top of the overflow tube.

When to call a pro

Getting help

Start with a licensed plumber for anything that involves cutting pipe, opening a wall, or work your local code requires a permit for. R.E. Merrill & Associates has handled industrial and municipal pumps and fluid systems since 1987 — contact R.E. Merrill & Associates.

Related across the site

Sources

More in this section