Sump pumps · basement pumps
Sump pump vs sewage ejector pump: what is the difference?
Both sit in a basin below the floor and both pump water up and out, so they get confused. They are not interchangeable. A sump pump moves groundwater and storm seepage away from the foundation. A sewage ejector pump lifts wastewater from a below-grade bathroom or laundry up to the building sewer or septic line.
Side-by-side
| Sump pump | Sewage ejector pump | |
|---|---|---|
| What it pumps | Clear groundwater from drain tile and seepage | Wastewater with solids from toilets, showers, sinks, and laundry below the sewer line |
| Basin | Open or loosely lidded pit, often with a perforated liner | Sealed, gas-tight basin with gasketed lid |
| Venting | Not tied to the plumbing vent system (a radon or airtight lid may be used) | Vented to the building vent stack per plumbing code |
| Solids handling | Small solids only (often around 1/2 inch or less, per the spec sheet) | Rated for solids, commonly around 2 inches; grinder pumps macerate solids for small pipes or long runs |
| Discharge | Outside, away from the foundation, per local code | Into the building sewer or septic line, with check valve and full-port shutoff |
| Permit | Varies; often for new pits or discharge changes | Commonly required for new installs |
How to tell which one you have
- Lid: a bolted, gasketed lid with a vent pipe through it is almost always an ejector. A loose or clear lid over a pit fed by drain tile is a sump.
- What drains into it: pipes from a basement toilet, shower, or washer mean an ejector. Perforated drain tile entering the pit means a sump.
- Where it discharges: a pipe that leaves the house to the yard is a sump. One that ties into the main drain or stack is an ejector.
- Pump label: check the model number against the manufacturer's spec sheet for "sump," "effluent," "sewage," or "grinder."
Effluent pumps: the in-between
Effluent pumps handle gray water or septic effluent with small solids. They appear in laundry basins and in septic pump chambers. They are not a substitute for a sewage ejector where toilets drain. See septic pump chambers and effluent pumps.
Common mistakes
- Draining a washer or basement sink into a sump pit. Many codes prohibit it, and soap, lint, and grease foul the pit and float. See sump pit smells.
- Unsealing an ejector lid to "check it." Sewer gas is a health and safety hazard; leave it to a plumber.
- Buying a replacement by horsepower alone. Match pump type, solids rating, and flow at your actual head.
- Skipping the high-water alarm on either basin. See sump alarms and Wi-Fi monitors.
Products and parts
- Zoeller M53 Mighty-Mate 1/3 HP — cast-iron sump pump for clear groundwater; confirm flow at your head
- Sewage ejector pumps (Amazon search, high to low) — for reference when talking with your plumber; check the solids rating and listing
- High-water alarms (Amazon search, high to low) — useful on sump and ejector basins alike
For commercial, multi-unit, or high-head pumping, ask R.E. Merrill & Associates about professional-grade pump options and sizing.
A licensed plumber should install or service any sewage ejector system, and a plumber or waterproofing pro can size a sump pump. R.E. Merrill & Associates has handled industrial and municipal pumps and fluid systems since 1987 — Contact R.E. Merrill & Associates.
Related across the site
Sources
- Sump, effluent, and sewage pump manufacturer specification sheets and installation manuals.
- Local plumbing codes on below-grade fixtures, ejector basins, and venting (which vary by jurisdiction).
- A licensed plumber or waterproofing contractor for the specific installation.