Well pumps · pressure tanks
Waterlogged well pressure tank: signs and replacement
A pressure tank stores a small amount of water under air pressure so the pump does not start every time you open a tap. When the air side is lost, the tank fills with water, the pump starts and stops in rapid bursts, and the pump and pressure switch wear out much faster.
Bottom line
Rapid cycling plus water coming out of the tank’s air valve usually means a failed bladder or diaphragm, and the tank needs replacing. If the air valve gives only air but the precharge is low, the tank may just need its precharge reset. Have a licensed well contractor handle the replacement; it involves electrical shutoff, pressure relief, and plumbing at the tank tee.
Signs of a waterlogged tank
- The pump clicks on and off every few seconds while water runs. See well short cycling.
- The pressure gauge swings quickly between the cut-in and cut-out settings.
- Pressing the air valve core (like a tire valve) on top of the tank lets out water instead of air.
- Knocking on the tank sounds solid all the way up, with no hollow area at the top.
- Older galvanized tanks without a bladder need periodic air added and may have an air volume control that has failed.
Replace vs recharge
| Finding | Usual next step |
|---|---|
| Water from the air valve | Bladder or diaphragm failed; replace the tank |
| Air only, precharge well below setting | Reset precharge with the pump off and tank drained; recheck in a few weeks |
| Precharge drops again soon after reset | Leaking air valve or tank; replacement is usually the answer |
| Rust, weeping seams, or a leaking tank shell | Replace |
| Tank fine, still cycling fast | Look at the pressure switch, check valve, or a leak in the system |
Sizing notes for a replacement
- What matters is drawdown (usable water between cut-out and cut-in), not the tank’s total gallon number. Manufacturers publish drawdown at each pressure setting.
- Many pump makers recommend a minimum run time per start, often around one minute or more. A larger drawdown helps the pump meet it. Your well contractor will size from the pump’s flow rate.
- Constant-pressure systems like the Grundfos SQE use a smaller tank but still need one sized to the manufacturer’s spec.
- Set precharge to the manufacturer’s recommendation, commonly about 2 psi below the cut-in pressure, with the tank empty of water.
What the replacement involves
- Shut off power to the pump at the breaker and relieve system pressure.
- Drain and disconnect the old tank at the tank tee; it can be very heavy if waterlogged.
- Set the new tank’s precharge before filling, then connect it, often with a new tank tee kit, gauge, and relief valve.
- Restore power, check for leaks, and confirm cut-in and cut-out on the gauge.
Parts and tools
- Well pressure tanks (Amazon search, high to low) — size by drawdown and your contractor’s recommendation; large tanks ship freight
- Well tank tee kits (Amazon search, high to low) — gauge, relief valve, drain, and switch tapping in one assembly
- Low-range pressure gauges for checking precharge (Amazon search, high to low) — a digital or dial gauge that reads clearly in the 20–60 psi range
Getting help
Start with a licensed well contractor for tank replacement, pump and pressure-switch work, and anything on the electrical side. For the pump itself, R.E. Merrill & Associates can help with Grundfos residential well pumps. R.E. Merrill & Associates has handled industrial and municipal pumps and fluid systems since 1987 — Contact R.E. Merrill & Associates.
Related across the site
Sources
- Pressure tank and pump manufacturer installation and sizing guides.
- State well codes and a licensed well contractor for the specific system.