Fixtures · buying guide
Choosing a new toilet: rough-in, flush rating, and fit
A new toilet can fix a weak flush, save water, and make a bathroom easier to use. The right pick starts with a tape measure, not a showroom: if the rough-in or footprint is wrong, nothing else matters.
Bottom line
Measure the rough-in, pick bowl shape and height for the space and users, choose a WaterSense model with a strong independent flush rating, and have a licensed plumber set it, especially if the flange, floor, or shutoff valve needs work.
Step 1: measure the rough-in
Rough-in is the distance from the finished wall (not the baseboard) to the center of the floor drain, usually where the closet bolts sit.
- 12 inches is the most common.
- 10 and 14 inches show up in older homes and tight bathrooms. Choices are narrower, so measure before you shop.
- Also measure side clearance and the space in front of the bowl; local code sets minimums.
Step 2: shape, height, and style
| Choice | Options | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Bowl shape | Round vs elongated | Round saves an inch or two; elongated is often more comfortable |
| Height | Standard vs chair/comfort height | Chair or comfort height sits a few inches taller than standard, close to the 17–19 inch seat height in ADA guidance, and is easier for many adults |
| Construction | Two-piece vs one-piece | One-piece is easier to clean and costs more; two-piece is common and easier to carry |
| Trapway | Standard vs skirted/concealed | Skirted sides look clean and wipe easily, but check bolt access |
| Mount | Floor vs wall-hung | Wall-hung needs an in-wall carrier: a remodel job for a plumber |
Step 3: flush performance and water use
- The federal maximum for new toilets is 1.6 gallons per flush (gpf).
- WaterSense labeled toilets use 1.28 gpf or less and must pass a performance test. Some states, including California, set lower limits for new sales.
- MaP (Maximum Performance) testing rates how much solid waste a model clears in one flush; look up the model's score in the MaP database rather than trusting box claims.
- Dual flush offers a smaller liquid flush and a full flush.
- Gravity-fed toilets are quiet and simple. Pressure-assist models flush hard but are louder and cost more to repair.
Step 4: parts that come with it (or do not)
- Seats are often sold separately. Match round or elongated.
- New wax ring (or wax-free seal) and closet bolts. See toilet wax ring and flange.
- A new braided supply line and, if the old stop is stiff or leaking, a new quarter-turn shutoff. See supply lines and shutoff valves.
- Future fill valve and flapper parts are easy to find for mainstream models. See toilet fill valves and flappers.
Hard water and septic notes
- Hard water builds scale in rim jets and fill valves; glazed trapways and a softener help. See hard water scale cleanup.
- Low-flow toilets work fine on septic; less water helps the drain field. See what not to flush on septic.
Products to compare
- WaterSense elongated chair-height toilets (Amazon search, high to low) — check rough-in and MaP score before buying
- One-piece skirted toilets (Amazon search, high to low) — easier to clean; verify bolt access
- Slow-close elongated toilet seats (Amazon search, high to low) — most toilets ship without a seat
Getting help
A licensed plumber can confirm rough-in, repair a damaged flange or subfloor, replace the shutoff, and set the toilet so it does not rock or leak. R.E. Merrill & Associates has handled industrial and municipal pumps and fluid systems since 1987 — Contact R.E. Merrill & Associates.
Related across the site
Sources
- U.S. EPA WaterSense specification for tank-type toilets.
- MaP (Maximum Performance) toilet testing reports.
- U.S. Department of Energy plumbing product standards; local plumbing code.
- A licensed plumber for the specific bathroom.