Well pumps · troubleshooting

Well pump won't shut off: what to check first

On a standard pressure-switch well system, the pump starts at the cut-in pressure and stops at the cut-out pressure (for example 40 and 60 psi on a 40/60 switch). If the pump runs and runs, either something is still using water, the pump cannot reach cut-out pressure, or the switch is not telling it to stop. A pump that never shuts off can overheat, run dry, or overpressure the system, so it is worth working through the checks quickly and safely.

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Product links below go to Amazon.

Bottom line Look at the pressure gauge first. If pressure is at or above cut-out and still climbing, turn off the pump breaker now: the switch is likely stuck and the system can overpressure. If pressure is stuck below cut-out, look for water use or a leak, then a clogged switch port, then a pump or well that cannot keep up. Electrical work and anything down the well belong with a licensed well contractor or electrician.

Read the gauge first

What the gauge showsLikely meaningFirst move
Pressure rises past cut-out and keeps goingPressure switch contacts stuck closed, or a clogged sensing port that does not see the pressureShut off the pump breaker; call a well contractor
Pressure sits steady a few psi below cut-outPump is close but cannot quite reach the setting: worn pump, low water level, or a switch set too high for the pumpCheck demand and leaks, then call a contractor
Pressure low or dropping while the pump runsHeavy demand, a leak, a split drop pipe, or the well is drawing downShut off water use; see pump runs but no water
Gauge needle does not move at allGauge may be broken or its port cloggedVerify with a second gauge — see well pressure gauges
Pump starts and stops rapidly rather than running nonstopA different problem: short cyclingWell pump short cycling

Constant-pressure systems (such as a Grundfos SQE with a controller) are designed to run longer at variable speed while water is in use. Long run times during demand are normal there; continuous running with every tap closed is not. See SQ vs SQE constant pressure.

Safe check order

  1. Close every tap and check for demand. Look for a running toilet, an irrigation zone, a softener or filter stuck in backwash, an outdoor hose, or a livestock waterer. See toilet fill valve and flapper fixes and softener water running to the drain.
  2. Look for a leak. With all water off, watch the gauge after the pump stops (or turn off the breaker once pressure is up). If pressure keeps falling, water is going somewhere: a leak in the house, the buried line from the well, or back down the well through a bad check valve. Wet spots in the yard between the well and the house are a clue.
  3. Check whether pressure is climbing past cut-out. If it is, turn off the pump breaker. Do not keep resetting it. Most systems have a pressure relief valve, but do not rely on it.
  4. Suspect the pressure switch. Burned or welded contacts can stick closed. The small tube or nipple under the switch can also clog with sediment or iron so the switch never sees the real pressure. Both are common, inexpensive fixes, but the switch has line voltage; turn off the breaker and verify power is off before opening the cover, or have an electrician or well contractor do it. See replacing a 40/60 pressure switch.
  5. Consider the pump and the well. A worn pump, a hole in the drop pipe, a stuck or leaking check valve, or a water level that has dropped can leave a pump running without reaching cut-out. These need a contractor with test equipment. See is my well running dry? and check valves and torque arrestors.
  6. Check the switch setting. If someone raised the cut-out pressure (for example from 40/60 to 50/70) and the pump was never sized for it, the pump may struggle to reach it. Settings should match the pump curve and the tank precharge; see pressure tank precharge.

Why not just let it run?

Tools and references

We do not link pumps on this page. Pump selection depends on well depth, yield, and pressure needs; get it sized by a well contractor or a Grundfos dealer.

Getting help

Start with a licensed well contractor (and a licensed electrician for wiring) to test the switch, check valve, pump amperage, and water level before replacing anything. If the pump itself needs replacing, R.E. Merrill & Associates has handled industrial and municipal pumps and fluid systems since 1987 and can help with Grundfos residential well pumps — contact R.E. Merrill & Associates.

Related across the site

Sources

More in this section